Let's imagine for a moment that we are standing in front of a cake counter. Chocolate or strawberry? We feel free in our decision. But are we really? In recent decades, neuroscience has gained amazing insights into precisely this question. And the answer? Well, it's more complex than a chocolate-strawberry cake with extra cream.
The famous Benjamin Libet experiment
Benjamin Libet, a pioneer in neuroscience, conducted a groundbreaking experiment in the 1980s. He had subjects perform a random hand movement and measured their brain activity while doing so. The surprising thing was that the brain showed a “readiness potential” 200–500 milliseconds before the test subjects consciously decided to move their hand. In short, the brain seems to make the decision before we even think about it! It's as if the brain decides and we follow suit later.
But does that mean that our will is completely predetermined? Not necessarily. Libet found that although we unconsciously prepare an action, we still have the option of stopping it at the last moment. This is known as the “veto right” or “free power of objection”. This gives us at least a little control over our actions – like an emergency brake for spontaneous impulses.
If our brain is already active before our conscious decision, are we merely spectators of our own lives? Fortunately not quite. Neuroscientists like John-Dylan Haynes have shown that our conscious will has at least a “stop button”. We can still prevent a decision that our brain has already prepared. This means that perhaps our first impulse is not free, but we have the last word – like with a bad joke that you don't say after all.
What's more, our brain is a real energy saver. It loves routines and habits. That's why many decisions are made on autopilot – from reaching for the coffee cup in the morning to choosing our favorite parking space. Driving is a perfect example: at first, we think about every move, but after years of practice, many things happen almost automatically. The brain simply tries not to dwell on unnecessary details.
The illusion of free will
Imagine you are standing in front of a wall of 20 different types of jam in the supermarket. Do you really think you are making a free decision? In fact, unconscious factors such as packaging, previous experiences and even your current mood influence your choice. Your brain loves efficient processes and often falls back on stored patterns – a kind of inner autopilot.
In addition, marketing, advertising and social norms have a significant influence on our decisions. Studies show that even the placement of products on the shelf or the color of packaging can influence our buying behavior. Often, we are not even aware of these influences. This creates the illusion of having made a completely free choice, when in reality many unconscious factors are at play.
Kahneman's System 1 and System 2 – the two bosses in our heads
In his theory of System 1 and System 2, Nobel Prize winner Daniel Kahneman showed that our thinking takes place in two parallel processes. System 1 is fast, intuitive and automatic – it often makes decisions unconsciously and is based on experience. System 2, on the other hand, is slow, analytical and requires conscious effort.
This means that many of our everyday decisions are made by System 1 without us consciously thinking about them. Only when a decision is more complex or requires conscious reflection does System 2 come into action. It's a bit like a company with two managers: System 1 makes quick, spontaneous decisions, while System 2 only takes over when things get tricky.
The role of the prefrontal cortex and the reptilian brain – thinking vs. instinct
Our brain is divided into different areas that perform different functions. Particularly relevant to the question of free will are the prefrontal cortex and the so-called “reptilian brain”.
The prefrontal cortex is our CEO, so to speak. It sits in the front area of the brain and is responsible for complex thinking, planning and impulse control. Without it, we would constantly be pressing the “right now!” button – be it when eating, shopping or making rash comments.
The reptilian brain, on the other hand, is our primeval security service. It is responsible for our basic survival mechanisms such as flight, fight or food search. Many instinctive reactions come from this area – so when you react impulsively in stressful situations or make decisions “on a whim”, your inner dinosaur is making itself felt.
The interaction between these two brain regions is crucial for our will: while the reptilian brain makes quick, automatic decisions, the prefrontal cortex can consciously intervene and weigh up alternative actions. This is how we can control our impulses – at least when we are not completely overtired or hungry.
What does modern neuroscience say?
Current studies show: free will is not completely abolished, but it is arguably less “free” than we think. Much of what we experience as spontaneous decisions is the result of unconscious neuronal processes. Nevertheless, there is hope for those who do not want to feel like remote-controlled beings. The ability to reflect on our impulses, to exercise conscious self-control and to actively shape our environment gives us at least some form of autonomy.
Furthermore, our consciousness can influence long-term decisions. For example, if you decide to eat healthier or exercise more, repetition and self-discipline can help you establish new habits. This means that while we may be influenced by unconscious processes at the moment of decision, our overarching consciousness can help determine the direction of our lives in the long term.
Conclusion: free, but not without limits
So do we have free will? The answer is: yes and no. Our brain makes many decisions unconsciously, but we have the opportunity to intervene. If you are aware of your own thought and behavior patterns, you can influence them – and that feels pretty much like freedom, doesn't it?
Neuroscience shows that our will is a complex interplay of unconscious processes, learned patterns, and conscious control. While we are not completely independent of these factors, we still have the ability to influence our behavior.
So, enjoy your cake – whether chocolate or strawberry – and be aware that your brain may have made the decision a long time ago. But in the end, it's still up to you to take the first bite!
Comments